A Mexican Sandwich – Torta Cubana

Last year, I shared a recipe for “la torta cubana”, probably one of the most popular Mexican sandwiches, served at street-food stands and restaurants alike; in spite of being named after a foreign country, this delicious treat was created in Mexico. The photo at the top of the post shows an authentic torta cubana at the champion of torta joints, a Don Polo™ restaurant in Mexico City, made with a telera, the original bun for tortas.  In my original post, I used a Kaiser bun, but since I shared the recipe for homemade teleras in my previous post, I thought of re-posting the story and recipe for this classic Mexican delight:

Torta Cubana – A Mexican Sandwich (Originally posted on June 10, 2019) 

Click here to go to printable recipe: Torta Cubana

In one of my earliest posts, I mentioned that when I was in middle school in Mexico City, a friend introduced me to “Tortas Don Polo”, a restaurant specializing in Mexican sandwiches (tortas) and smoothies (licuados). Established in 1958 by Leopoldo (Polo) Sánchez Preciado, it became very popular, especially for its delicious “tortas cubanas” (Cuban tortas.) In yet another of my early posts, I wrote about the three urban legends regarding the naming of this sandwich:  “We know tortas are Mexican sandwiches, and it is generally accepted that the cubanas in particular, were invented in Mexico City sometime in the 1950s (note: the Cuban sandwich is a different preparation, popular in Miami); how they were named is a different matter.  The three most popular stories are: 1) That the creator had a small torta stand on “República de Cuba” Street, in Downtown Mexico City, so the sandwich was named after the location. 2) That Mexican men described Cuban ladies as “having everything”: elegance, beauty and intelligence; the curious analogy is – remember, this is the 1950s – that tortas cubanas are filled with lots of ingredients: meats, cheese, veggies, or “everything on.” 3) The last story, closer to a fairy tale, is that Fidel Castro himself invented this Mexican sandwich  in a restaurant in Downtown Mexico City during his brief exile in the country (1955-1956), and it was named cubana after his homeland.”  There is no consensus to this date on which story (if any) is right.

I recently had a chance to go back to the original “Don Polo” (which now has branches, but the original is on 86-A Félix Cuevas/Eje 7, Del Valle). I felt transported through a time gap, it looked just as I remembered it was in the last Millennium (hehe).  The nice servers were still wearing uniforms with white aprons and, as soon as you seat at one of their square tables, they promptly arrange a paper placemat on the melamine top, as well as a laminated menu with photographs of some of their specialties:

Don Polo mat and menu

Of course the chairs and stools had those old-fashioned vinyl seats, I mean, just look at the precious coffee machine on the counter:

002 Don Polo coffee machine

That sight, and the sound and smell of fresh coffee brewing in the background (not sure if from the same machine, but still) felt like a balm to my senses … I looked at the menu just for the memories, but I knew I was going to order a torta cubana. I also ordered a licuado (smoothie), and they came along with a saucer filled with their homemade escabeche-style pickled jalapeño peppers and carrots:

003 Don Polo torta cubana and mamey smoothie

It was just as I remembered it; buttered crusty bun, grilled and filled with layers of refried beans, avocado, ham, American style yellow cheese and a pile of their house pork roast. I added a generous amount of spicy vegetables to my torta cubana:

004 Don Polo torta cubana and pickled jalapenos and carrots

Needless to say, I thought that, once back home, I had to recreate the experience.

Torta Cubana

Printable recipe: Torta Cubana

Ingredients (for one sandwich)

1 large crusty bun (teleras are the original, but Portuguese buns, Kaisers or Calabrese buns are good options)
Butter, at room temperature
½ to ¾ cup cooked pork roast; sliced (for example, leftover roast from this recipe)
1 slice ham
1 slice American style yellow cheese (or a thin slice of Cheddar)
¼ cup refried beans
½ avocado, sliced
Side: Escabeche-style pickled jalapeños and carrots, sliced (click here for my recipe, or canned)

Slice bun in half, lengthwise; spread butter on the cut side of both halves; place on a skillet, pre-heated over medium heat, butter side down, along with the pork and ham photo below, left); stir pork and flip ham after a couple of minutes, then place cheese on top of the ham and lightly butter the outer sides of the bun (photo below, right):

When the cheese starts to melt, flip along with the ham on top of the roast, flip buns to crisp the outer sides, and spread beans on bottom half of the bun (phot below, left).  After one more minute, place meats and cheese on the top half of the bun; transfer bottom half to a plate, bean side up, and top with avocado slices, then place the other half on top (photo below, right):

Serve with the jalapeño peppers and carrots en escabeche on the side, to add to the sandwich to taste:

005 torta cubana

I even made a licuado (click here for my recipe).  Overall, the meal was very close to the one at “Don Polo”, except for the bun; I used a Kaiser bun because the authentic teleras are not available around here; the closest, I think, is the Portuguese style crusty bun.

Update April 2020: With my own teleras, I can aspire to an even better homemade torta cubana, closer to the one shown at the top of the post.  I will prepare this treat again for sure; maybe not tonight because I am not eating meat during the Christian Lenten season, but soon.

I am bringing my recipe at Over the Moon #219, graciously hosted by Bev @ Eclectic Red Barn, and Marilyn @ Marilyn’s Treats.

I am also joining Classy Flamingos Blog Party #97 with Linda @ poinsettiadr.com.

6 thoughts on “A Mexican Sandwich – Torta Cubana

  1. I have had a Cuban sandwich before. First of all, I am shocked that it is named a Cuban if it was made in Mexico. Who decided that? Secondly, your recipe sounds much better than the one I had. I will have to try it.


    1. The Cuban sandwich is from Cuba and popularized in Miami. The Cuban torta (Mexican sandwich) was invented in Mexico, and there are a few anecdotal stories on why it is called “Cuban”. I listed those stories, including the legend of Fidel Castro himself creating this torta during his brief exile in Mexico. I hope you get to try this recipe, let me know how you liked it. Thank you for your comment!

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Thank you for sharing at #OverTheMoon. Pinned and shared. Have a lovely week. I hope to see you at next week’s party too! Pleas stay safe and healthy. Come party with us at Over The Moon! Catapult your content Over The Moon! @marilyn_lesniak @EclecticRedBarn

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s